AI engineering
Choosing Between an AI Agent and a Defined Workflow
Choose autonomy based on the task’s uncertainty. Compare defined workflows and AI agents through control, evaluation, recovery, and real user outcomes.
The word agent can hide important architectural choices. Anthropic distinguishes workflows with predefined code paths from agents that dynamically choose their process and tools. Both can use language models. The useful decision is how much of the next step should be determined by application logic, and how much genuinely needs flexible reasoning over an unfamiliar situation.
Map decisions before choosing a framework
Write the task as a sequence of inputs, decisions, and outcomes. Identify which decisions are stable business rules and which depend on interpreting open-ended material. A fixed approval threshold, required field check, or known routing table belongs naturally in code. A research task with unpredictable evidence may need more flexible exploration.
Also define the stopping condition. A workflow may finish after a validated record is created. An agent needs a similarly concrete definition of completion, plus limits on steps, elapsed time, and tool use. Without those boundaries, the system can continue producing activity after it has stopped making useful progress.
Compare two hypothetical implementations
Consider a hypothetical team processing inbound project requests. If every request needs extraction, completeness checking, and a draft response, a defined workflow may be sufficient. Each stage has a known input and output, and a human can review the resulting draft.
Now consider investigating why a customer integration failed. The relevant logs, configuration, and supporting documents may vary by incident. An agent could choose different read-only diagnostic tools based on observed results. Even here, the application can keep consequential changes behind explicit review and use deterministic code for authentication, rate limits, and evidence storage.
Evaluate the added flexibility
Build a baseline with the simplest process that can plausibly meet the requirement. Measure task completion, correction effort, unsupported conclusions, time, and resource use. Add agent behavior where the baseline fails because it cannot choose the right next step, rather than because the underlying data is missing or an API is unreliable.
Test interruptions and partial progress. Users should be able to see what completed, what remains uncertain, and whether any external state changed. Keep an operational record of tool results and decisions without requiring the interface to expose private internal reasoning. The product should communicate evidence and actions in a form a user can assess.
